Only The Rulers Will Be The Exceptions
October 31,2026



"Atlas Shrugged" by Ayn Rand is one of my favorite novels but one complaint I've had about the work is that the villains are perhaps too broadly drawn; they could've been improved, IMO, had they been portrayed as more nuanced, as I believe most people really are. I felt the villains in the book act in ways that real people -at least the sensible ones- just wouldn't. And then Robert Reich, Secretary of Labor during the Clinton administration, goes and tells us what he thinks.

In the past, I've admired some of Mr. Reich's work, particulary the documentary film "Inequality fo All" (2013) which was based upon his book "Aftershock: The Next Economy and America's Future" (2010). I was especially taken by his observation that, in the past, think-tanks of both right and left-leaning tendency came to a similar conclusion: that middle-class Americans were getting too big for their britches in terms of their various expectations. How this could be undermined should be obvious (population dilution) when measured against subsequent events.

That was then, however, and my admiration for the man is a past matter. A few days ago, he said that Elon Musk should be "defunded" and one way to achieve this would be to nationalize the SpaceX Corporation. Never mind that this wouldn't defund Musk at all as the 5th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution would require that owners be fairly compensated in the event of government seizure, meaning Musk could be paid close to a trillion dollars for his stake, at the current market value, no: my point here is that, in suggesting this, Mr. Reich is doing exactly what a Rand villain would do; outrageously advocating seizure of property for political purposes.

Hey, if you don't like what Musk is doing, there are other rocket companies out there and other telecommunications businesses...so why SpaceX? Under the 5th Amendment, Musk would still be fantastically wealthy and thus able to continue his various endeavors in opposition to those with political views and agendas similar to those of Mr. Reich, so again, why SpaceX? Because its competitors simply can't do what SpaceX does and, as such, it's indispensable. Which brings up the topic of exceptionalism.

I've listend to people like Barack Obama and Elizabeth Warren rant about what they seem to think is the myth of exceptionalism. People like Musk aren't so special, these "leaders" say, because he didn't make those things. While it's true that people like Steve Jobs and Elon Musk et al. did not physically build their companies' products, those products wouldn't have existed without them. Yes, it takes thousands of workers on many levels to create these things...but most of those workers can be indidvidually replaced; perhaps all but a few of the most exceptional scientists and engineers can be replaced. The most exceptional.

Those who found or run a company decide which products will be made, the direction of resource allocation, which research will be emphasized -and the final goals. Many fail and we read about them all the time; the CEO whose poor judgment ran the company into the ground is not an unfamiliar tale. The best rise to the top often through some combination of exceptional intelligence, skill, judgment, perserverance or even luck (never discount luck!). As it was their actions as individuals that led their ventures in the directions taken, paths another may not have selected, those leaders simply could not be replaced.

To me, it seems some members of the political leadership here in America want the products of exceptional people without having to deal with the people themselves. I think they'd prefer how it is in China. Remember Jack Ma? He's the billionaire founder of Chinese company Alibaba. For years he was a global public figure...until he ran his a mouth a bit too much, criticizing the Chinese government. Soon after, the Chinese government canceled an IPO Ma had planned (which would've been the largest in history at that time) and Mr. Ma assumed a dramatically lower prolife amid rumors he'd been detained or placed under house arrest in China. This is the stuff of dreams for many American politicians.

Yes, some of our leaders may choose to call exceptionalism a fantasy but if even the aformentioned aren't exceptional, where does that leave regular folks like us?

Last year, Senator Bernie Sanders and Congresswoman AOC embarked upon their "Fighting Oligarchy" tour where they held gatherings and gave speeches in favor of their broad agenda. Recall how this tour was conducted? Private jets, chauffered limousines and deluxe accomodations. But wait, aren't these individuals also champions of the Green agenda? Private fucking jets?? Aren't those also the symbols of excess greed both corporate and private and tools of the existing "oligarchy"? And this was a tour meant to promote populism?? When asked why they needed private jet travel, Mr. Sanders explained that their tight schedule made commercial travel impossible. Of course they couldn't wait in lines like the little people...like us. Why did they need to appear in person at all? If they wished to reach audiences at scale, couldn't they have appeared simultaneously and live on large screens at mass-event venues? Couldn't they have led by example and used technology to lower the carbon footprint of their tour while potentially reaching far, far more people than they ever could in person?

I wondered about this for about 2 seconds until the reason became clear for me; this tour wasn't about the stated reasons, no. In my opinion, this was about testing the waters; could they use the tools and methods of "excess" in spreading their message without being called out on it? Could they separate themselves from the little people, place themselves above the masses by using executive travel and accomodations and get away with it? Would their followers -and perhaps others- accept them offering themselves as blatant replacements for the oligarchy they proclaim to protest against?

To me, it too-often appears that those who rage most prominently against the super-successful always seem to possess multiple homes and large fortunes of their own. They tell us they need excessive "platforms" to spread their messages and thus need to live with commensurate excessiveness while the rest of us must hunker down and sacrifice.

In their world, there would be no "special" individuals; if you develop something remarkable, something you could hold up as an example of your own prowess or achievement, but something that someone in power sees as useful, it will be taken from you and you'll be sent back to the mines like a good little serf. Mr. Obama and Ms. Warren would tell you it's not yours anyway, and if it was never yours, it's that much easier for them to make it theirs. In their world, "those billionaires" would be pulled down and their private islands, mansions, jets and money seized for "public use"...but you don't really think "public use" means for you and me...do you?